The Truth About Prong Collars


Table of Contents

Reading Time: 19 minutes

Do you have a dog that pulls on the leash? If so, you may be considering using a prong collar to train him. However, it’s important to understand how they work and the potential risks involved before you do. This blog post will discuss prong collars and help you decide if they are right for your dog.

What Are Prong Collars?

Prong collars are also known as pinch collars. They work by applying pressure to the dog’s neck when he pulls on the leash. The pressure is released when the dog stops pulling. Prong collars are made of metal and have blunt prongs that point inward. They can be adjusted to fit snugly around the dog’s neck.

Will a Prong Collar Make My Dog Bleed?

No, a prong collar will not make your dog bleed. As I said, the prongs are blunt. They’re designed to apply pressure, not puncture the skin. However, if the collar is not fitted properly, it can cause your dog discomfort or bruising.

Are Prong Collars Cruel?

Prong collars are controversial, and there is a lot of misinformation out there about them. For example, some people believe that prong collars are cruel and abusive, but this is not true. Used properly, prong collars are a safe and effective way to train dogs who pull on the leash. However, to start with, they should usually only be used under the supervision of a qualified trainer or behaviorist.

There are some risks associated with prong collars, but these can be minimized by using them correctly. The most common risk with prong collars is that the dog will associate the discomfort with the person walking him, which can lead to aggression. This kind of negative association is another reason why it’s best to use a professional trainer until you’re sure you know how to use the collar properly.

Do Prong Collars Hurt the Dog’s Throat?

No, prong collars do not hurt the dog’s throat. The pressure is applied to the sides of the neck, not the front. If the collar is fitted correctly, it should not be too tight or too loose.

If you decide to go with a prong collar, be sure to purchase one that is made of high-quality materials and is properly fitted to your dog’s neck. Never leave the collar on your dog unsupervised, and always remove it when he is not being trained. A prong collar can be a safe and effective way to train your dog with proper use.

The bottom line is that prong collars are a tool, and like any tool, they can be misused. Used correctly, they are safe and effective. Used incorrectly, any collar can cause harm. So, if you decide to use a prong collar, make sure that you understand how to use it correctly and always supervise your dog while he is wearing it. Then, again, work with a pro until you’re sure you’re ready to go it alone.

Are Prong Collars Legal?

Prong collars are legal in most states, but there are some places where they are banned or regulated. For example, in the state of California, prong collars can’t be used to tether a dog.

How Can I Find a Dog Trainer?

If you’re looking for a dog trainer, the best place to start is by asking your veterinarian or another pet professional for a recommendation. You can also search online or look in the yellow pages.

When choosing a trainer, be sure to interview them and ask about their experience with prong collars. Make sure that they are certified and that you are comfortable with their training methods.

What Are Aversive Trainers?

These are the people you don’t want to deal with. Aversive dog trainers are those who use punishment-based methods to train dogs. They’ll often misuse electric shock collars, choke chains, and prong collars, all of which can be useful and not cruel in the right hands.

A good dog trainer uses positive methods, which are quite the opposite. When the dog does something right, a good trainer rewards him with praise and/or treats. It’s not the tools; it’s the kindness that makes all the difference between aversive training methods and positive training methods.

Should Prong Collars Only Be Used on Large Dogs?

Prong collars can be used on any size dog, but they are often recommended for larger breeds. This is because larger dogs have more neck and shoulder mass, making it less likely that the pressure from the collar will cause pain or injury.

Smaller dogs can also benefit from prong collars, but it’s important to use a smaller size collar and to be extra careful not to pull too hard or jerk the leash. Even with a small dog, if the dog pulls too hard on the leash, he can be hard to handle. I’d suggest not slapping on a pinch collar right away, though. Instead, try a fine link choke collar.

Imagine that you have three dogs – a tiny Shih Tzu, a medium-sized Labrador Retriever, and a gigantic English Mastiff. Those three dogs could all have very different needs when it comes to using the right training tool.

Now, imagine that you take your dogs to the dog park one at a time. You’re up close and personal with other dogs. Your Shih Tzu lunges at other dogs, and you need to be able to stop him quickly and effectively. Sure, he’s little, but a prong collar might be just what he needs.

Your Mastiff, on the other hand, is laid-back and lazy. He’s never given you any trouble, and you’re confident that he never will. So just leave him in a flat collar.

Your Lab is usually good on leash but likes to take off after squirrels. He’s not all that big, and unless you’re not all that strong, you can probably handle him with a choke collar. If you need a bit more control, you can consider a prong collar, but why go for the most extreme solution right out of the gate?

You get the idea. Three dogs, three different levels of control. Determine what you really need, and avoid overkill.

What Is a Choke Collar?

A choke is a type of training collar that is made of metal links. The links are put together in such a way that when the dog pulls, the collar tightens around his neck. This provides a gentle corrective action that can be used to train the dog not to pull on the leash.

Used properly, a choke chain will not harm the dog’s trachea or neck. Just don’t use the collar to pull the dog off his feet. If you’re in doubt as to the proper way to use a choke, get a pro to show you the ropes.

Are Choke Collars Dangerous?

If used properly, they’re no more dangerous than prong collars. A choke isn’t meant to replace a regular flat collar. Your dog should usually wear a flat collar and only have a choke on his neck for training purposes.

If you’re wondering why that is, let me tell you a story. I have a friend who always had choke collars on her Rottweilers. For years, nothing went wrong. Then one day, my friend went out to get groceries and left her dogs at home. When she got back, she discovered, to her horror, that one of her Rotts had somehow gotten the ring on the leash end of his choke collar caught on a cupboard doorknob and was strangling. That poor dog!

I know; what are the odds of something like that happening? Probably pretty slim. The point is, the odds notwithstanding, it DID HAPPEN. Fortunately, my friend was able to remove the ring from the knob without too much difficulty and free the dog’s head, despite the dog trying desperately to pull away from the source of the discomfort and therefore helping the chain to strangle him. But what if she’d been longer getting home?

Don’t leave a dog unattended when wearing a choke collar. Period. End of sentence.

Is a Shock Collar Better Than a Choke Collar or a Prong Collar?

A shock collar is a type of training collar that delivers an electric shock to the dog when he exhibits certain behaviors. For example, some dogs will learn not to bark excessively if they receive a mild shock every time they start to bark.

Shock collars can be effective, but they should only be used as a last resort after other methods, such as positive reinforcement have failed. Used improperly, shock collars can cause physical pain or even death. It’s a very bad idea to start using a shock collar without first working with a professional dog trainer.

If the problem is leash pulling, a shock collar might not do you much good. The poor dog won’t know where the shock is coming from and will be just as likely to try to run even farther from you, thus pulling even more on the leash.

What Kind of Collar Should I Use on a Dangerous Dog?

If you think your dog is dangerous, you have bigger problems than what kind of collar to use, but no, you should not use a prong collar on a dangerous dog without first seeking professional assistance.

If your dog is aggressive toward people or other animals, the best thing to do is get professional help. A behaviorist can work with you to find out what’s causing the aggression and how to deal with it. In some cases, medication may be necessary.

I’m not a big fan of “puppies on Prozac,” but then neither am I a fan of using medication on humans when therapy and/or behavioral modification are better solutions. That said, sometimes bad behavior is due to a chemical imbalance in the brain, and it can be corrected with the proper medication.

In the meantime, you’ll need to take some precautions. First, make sure the dog is always wearing a muzzle when he’s around people or other animals. Second, once your professional dog trainer has also trained you in the proper use of different collars, you can use a prong or shock collar to keep him under control when you’re out walking. And third, never leave him unattended in a public place.

While it’s important to be safe, it’s also important to remember that most dogs are not aggressive by nature. With the right training and management, even the most aggressive dog can learn to live peacefully with people and other animals.

What Are the Most Aggressive Dog Breeds?

Every breed of dog has had a turn at being considered the most aggressive. In the 1970s, it was the German Shepherd. It was the Doberman in the 1980s. Fast-forward to the 1990s, and everyone was worried about Rottweilers. Today, the Pit Bull, once considered being so gentle that it was a “nanny” to any number of children, is getting a turn.

So what are the most aggressive dog breeds? Generally speaking, they’re the ones that are used for improper purposes, like dogfighting or guarding a dealer’s drug stash. Criminals want big, vicious dogs, and they will abuse those dogs and use aversive training methods to get the sort of dog they want.

The most aggressive dog breeds are those that were bred for fighting or guarding, such as the Pit Bull, Rottweiler, and German Shepherd. However, any dog can be aggressive if he’s not properly trained and socialized. Therefore, it’s important to remember that aggression is not a breed-specific trait; it’s a behavior that any dog can exhibit. And also, remember, even the breeds that are believed to be the most aggressive can be good family pets if they’re properly trained and socialized.

Simply stated, the issue isn’t the breed of dog. It’s the type of person.

What if We Just Banned Dogs That Are Considered to Be Vicious?

Okay, let’s talk about breed bans. A dog breed ban is a law that prohibits the ownership of certain breeds of dogs. These bans are often put in place after a serious dog attack occurs, and they typically target supposedly “dangerous” breeds like Pit Bulls, Rottweilers, and German Shepherds.

Dog breed bans are controversial, but they shouldn’t be. They should just be thrown out with the rest of the trash. This is because there is no evidence to suggest that banning a certain breed of dog will reduce the number of dog attacks. In fact, these bans often lead to an increase in the number of abandoned and homeless dogs of the targeted breeds. Pit Bulls, for example, are one of the most popular breeds in shelters today because so many states have enacted breed-specific legislation. If you’re considering adopting a dog, be sure to check your local laws to see if there are any breed restrictions in place.

Does a Dog Breed Ban Ever Work? What if It Saves One Life?

You might think that if we ban supposedly dangerous dog breeds, there would be no more dangerous dogs. You would be wrong.

There is no evidence that breed bans work. In fact, there’s plenty of evidence to the contrary. For example, in the U.S., cities with breed bans have seen an increase in the number of bites, not a decrease. And in Canada, where there is no such thing as a pit bull ban, studies have shown that there are fewer bites per capita than in the U.S.

So if breed bans don’t work, what does? The answer is simple: responsible ownership. That means spaying or neutering your dog, providing him with proper training and socialization, and never leaving him unattended in a public place. It also means not giving in to the temptation to buy a “dangerous” breed of dog just because you think it’s cool.

Be a responsible owner, and don’t contribute to the problem of dog bites. It’s not worth the risk to your family or your community.

Got It. Can We Talk More About Collars?

Of course, that’s what we’re here for. You want to talk more about what kind of collars your dog feels most comfortable wearing. You want to avoid pain and be able to walk nicely with your dog.

In addition to using a prong collar or a choke chain, you could consider a martingale collar, herm Sprenger collar, or a dog harness. Head halters are also good alternatives. Let’s talk about these alternatives to prong collars.

What Is a Martingale Collar?

This is a type of dog collar that tightens when the dog pulls. It’s also sometimes called a limited-slip collar or a Greyhound collar. This collar is used to prevent dogs from slipping out of their collars and escaping.

A martingale collar is made with two loops: The larger loop goes around the dog’s neck and the smaller loop attaches to the leash. When the dog pulls, the smaller loop tightens, causing the larger loop to tighten as well. This gentle constriction reminds the dog not to pull and makes it more comfortable for him to walk on a leash.

Martingale collars are safe for all dogs when used as directed but not suitable for all dogs or all situations. For example, if you have a particularly strong or stubborn dog, a martingale collar may not be the best choice. You should also avoid using one if your dog is prone to neck injuries.

Ask your veterinarian or a professional trainer for guidance if you’re not sure whether a martingale collar is right for your dog.

What Is a Head Halter?

Head halters are halters that fit around the dog’s muzzle and attach to the leash at the back of the neck. They provide more control over the dog than a traditional collar because they allow you to steer the head of the dog. Head halters can be helpful if your dog is particularly strong or stubborn.

Head halters are not suitable for all dogs, and it can take some time to get used to wearing them. If you’re considering on as a type of restraint, you’ll probably be fine on your own, but it couldn’t hurt to work with a pro in the early stages.

What Is a Herm Sprenger Collar?

A Herm Sprenger collar is a type of prong collar that has been designed to be more comfortable for the dog. It is made with blunt-ended prongs that are less likely to cause injury.

Herm Sprenger collars are not suitable for all dogs, and they should only be used under the guidance of a professional trainer.

What Is a Dog Harness?

A dog harness is a type of collar that fits around the dog’s chest and torso. It is often used for dogs who pull on the leash, as it provides more control over the dog’s body than a traditional collar.

Dog harnesses are not suitable for all dogs, and although they’re fine for inexperienced owners to use, you might do better under the guidance of a professional trainer.

When Should I Consider Prong Collars?

Prong collars should only be used under the guidance of a professional trainer. They are not suitable for all dogs, and if used incorrectly, they can cause injury. If you’re going to use a prong collar, it should only be as a last resort after other methods, such as positive reinforcement training, have failed.

Can I Find Extra Links Online to Learn More About Good Dog Collars?

Yes. I think that one of the best is the WebMD site for pets. They talk about different types of collars and can go a long way in guiding you toward finding the best way of finding the collar that is right for your dog. Not everyone wants to resort to prong collars, even though they can be very effective in some situations where regular collars just don’t get the job done.

So What Is the Best Collar for My Dog?

The best collar for your dog is the one that is most comfortable for him and that you feel most comfortable using. Unfortunately, there is no single “best” collar for all dogs, as each dog is different. For example, some dogs do well with prong collars, while others do better with martingale collars or head halters. The best way to find out is to experiment with different types of collars and see what works best for your dog.

The best collar for your dog might be a prong collar. It might be a choke chain. On the other hand, it might be nothing more than a standard collar. Professional dog trainers use prong collars, choke collars, and even shock collars when dealing with difficult dogs. Gentle leaders, though, use them only when absolutely necessary.

What’s the Final Word on Whether You Should Use a Prong Collar as a Training Tool?

Using a prong collar as a training tool is a last resort. It’s what you do when you have no other way of controlling your dog. Are prong collars cruel? No, they’re not. Most dog trainers say that there’s nothing wrong with prong collars if they’re properly used. If reward-based methods fail and your dog is hard to control, many trainers will suggest using a prong.

A prong is just a training tool like any other training tool – good in the right hands and bad in the wrong hands. Let your dog wear a prong collar if it helps with training. It won’t hurt your dog’s skin, and it won’t hurt your dog’s neck.

If you’re a new dog owner, you should probably get some assistance from a pro before thinking about using a prong collar.

Okay, I Know About Collars Now. Can You Help Me With Other Dog-related Questions?

Oh, you have other questions? Fine, hit me with them! We don’t just have to talk about pinch collars. We can talk about dog training, personality, and anything else that interests you.

Is My Dog Bad?

No, your dog is not bad. Dogs are not capable of malice or cruelty, so if your dog is behaving in a way that you don’t like, it is likely due to a lack of training or a misunderstanding on his part. There is no need to punish your dog for misbehaving – instead, focus on positive reinforcement and rewards-based training to help him learn what you expect from him.

Can I Make a Bad Dog Good?

Again, there are no bad dogs. But yes, you can correct bad behavior. Dogs are not born bad – they become bad through lack of training, poor socialization, or exposure to negative experiences. With patience and consistency, you can train your dog to be the well-behaved companion you’ve always wanted.

What’s the Best Way to Train My Dog?

There is no single “best” way to train your dog – different dogs will respond to different methods. However, most experts agree that positive reinforcement training, in which you reward your dog for good behavior, is the most effective and humane method of training. There are many resources available to help you get started with positive reinforcement training, including books, websites, and professional dog trainers.

What if My Dog Is Untrainable?

There is no such thing as an untrainable dog – every dog can be trained, given enough time, patience, and consistency. If you’re having trouble training your dog, seek out the assistance of a professional dog trainer or behaviorist. They can help you identify the root of the problem and come up with a plan to address it.

Dogs often end up in rescue facilities because their humans haven’t properly trained them. Unfortunately, rescue dogs can also be among the most difficult dogs to train if they’ve been abused. If that’s the issue with your dog, make sure to use kind, gentle training methods. Aversive methods aren’t the best course of action for any dog and are even less effective with rescue dogs.

Why Else Would a Dog Be in a Rescue Facility?

There are many reasons why a dog might end up in a rescue facility. Some dogs are surrendered by their owners because they can no longer care for them. Others are abandoned or found as strays. Still, others come from puppy mills or commercial breeding operations. Dogs with separation anxiety sometimes end up in shelters because of excessive barking. Whatever the reason, all dogs in rescue deserve a second chance at a loving home.

If you’re thinking about adopting a rescue dog, be prepared to put in some extra time and effort to help him adjust to his new life. Rescue dogs often need a bit more patience and understanding than other dogs, but the rewards of rescuing are immeasurable.

What Is Separation Anxiety in Dogs?

Separation anxiety is a condition in which dogs experience distress and behavioral problems when they are separated from their guardians. Dogs with this issue may bark, whine, howl, chew on objects, urinate or defecate inside the house, and attempt to escape from the home or yard. It is a serious condition that can cause a great deal of stress for both dogs and their guardians.

If you think your dog may be suffering from this disorder, please consult with a qualified professional to discuss treatment options. With proper treatment, most dogs can learn to cope with their condition and live happy, healthy lives.

How Can I Stop My Dog From Barking?

This may sound a bit counter-intuitive, but one of the best ways to stop your dog from barking is to let him bark! What you do is gently say “Quiet” from time to time. Then when the dog finally IS quiet, say “Quiet” again, pet him, and give him a treat.

Don’t shout at your dog. This is another of those aversive methods that do no good. Your dog won’t know why you’re mad at him, and it will do nothing to discourage the barking.

Patience is very much the key here. It will take a while, but eventually, your dog will get the idea that good things happen when he stops barking. He’ll be more than happy to be quiet in exchange for a treat. Eventually, he’ll connect the command “Quiet” all on its own, and you won’t need to resort to treats. Although there’s nothing wrong with adding in a treat from time to time just because you love your dog!

Do Aversive Methods Ever Work?

Sadly, yes, they do. But a good dog owner doesn’t want his dog to be stressed and unhappy. So he might obey you if you shout at your dog or yank on the leash. But he’ll also fear you, and that doesn’t make for a healthy relationship with your dog.

Why Is My Dog Rejecting Her Puppies?

Wow, we’re really going further afield now! But that’s okay.

There are many reasons why a dog might reject her puppies, but (at the risk of stating the obvious) it all boils down to the fact that she is simply not ready to be a mother. First, it could be because she’s too young – you should never breed a bitch in her first heat. But, on the other hand, she might also be too old and unable to cope with rambunctious youngsters.

If your mother’s dog is rejecting her puppies, the first thing you should do is arrange for a veterinary examination. There could be an underlying cause – if she’s ill, she will probably want to devote all her physical resources to staying alive. Nursing the puppies will take second place.

Some mothers are actually afraid of their puppies and may even try to kill them. If this is the case, you’re going to have to remove the puppies from her and handle the feeding yourself. You can buy canine milk replacer at most feed stores and offer it until the puppies are able to take solid food.

Talk to your vet if you’re concerned about your dog’s rejection of her puppies. They will be able to help you determine the cause and find a solution that is best for both you and your dog.

When Should I Take My Dog to the Vet?

If your dog is sick or injured, you should take him to the vet right away. But there are other times when you might want to consider making an appointment.

For example, if your dog is suddenly acting differently, it could be a sign that something is wrong, and a trip to the vet may be needed. Likewise, if your dog is eating or drinking less, losing weight, or seems to be in pain, these could also be signs that something is wrong, and a trip to the vet may be needed.

Every dog should see a veterinarian twice a year for a checkup. Routine shots will be administered during these checkups.

Of course, if you’re ever unsure whether or not you should take your dog to the vet, it’s always best to err on the side of caution and make an appointment. Your vet will be able to help you figure out what’s going on and whether or not your dog needs medical attention.

Should I Buy Pet Insurance for My Dog?

You will need to make this decision based on your own personal circumstances. There are a number of factors that you will need to consider, such as the type and amount of coverage you want, the age and health of your dog, and the cost of premiums.

You can get more information about pet insurance and compare different plans at the ASPCA’s website.

When it comes to your dog’s health and well-being, you want to make sure you’re doing everything you can to keep him healthy and happy. Pet insurance can help you do that by giving you peace of mind and financial protection in case your dog ever needs emergency medical treatment.

If you’re independently wealthy, you can probably forego pet insurance. If you’re not, though, keep in mind that many procedures are very expensive. For instance, if your dog needs a hip replacement, that can cost you upwards of $3,000 USD – and that’s just for ONE hip!

How Many Dog Owners Are There in the United States?

You’re a regular little question box, aren’t you? LOL! I’m kidding – I love talking about dogs and am more than happy to answer your questions.

Approximately 68 million American households own a pet, which equates to 84. pets per household. Of those pets, 39% are dogs—so that’s about 32.75 million households with at least one dog. In other words, there are almost as many households with dogs as there are with children!

What Should I Do if My Dog Doesn’t Like My Children?

This is a difficult situation to be in, but there are a few things you can try. First, make sure that your children respect your dog’s space and not be too rough with him. It’s also important to socialize your dog from a young age so that he is used to being around children.

If you have tried these things and your dog still doesn’t like your children, you may need to consider finding a new home for him – or for the kids. This is a difficult decision to make, but sometimes it’s the best thing for both your dog and your family.

Are Most Dogs Good With Children?

Yes, most dogs are good with children. However, there are certain breeds that may not be a good fit for a family with young kids. Like Australian shepherds and border collies, these include herding dogs who may try to herd your children.

Size is also something to consider. Like a Chihuahua, a very small dog may love kids but could be easily injured and snappish if the kids are too rough. By the same token, a large dog like a Rottweiler, or a giant breed like an English Mastiff, could accidentally hurt a toddler by knocking him over.

So, while most dogs are good with children, it’s important to do your research before getting a dog to make sure you’re choosing a breed that will fit well into your family. And, once you have your dog, be sure to socialize it and provide plenty of positive experiences so that it grows up to be a happy, well-adjusted dog.


I hope you’ve enjoyed this article about prong collars and that I’ve been able to answer your other questions as well.

Though prong collars are effective training tools, they can also be dangerous if used incorrectly. Therefore, it’s important to understand how and when to use them properly in order to achieve the desired results without causing any harm.

Prong collars work by applying pressure to the dog’s neck, which causes an uncomfortable sensation that the dog will want to avoid. The dog will then associate this unpleasant sensation with whatever it was doing at the time and will be less likely to repeat the behavior in the future.

Are prong collars cruel? No, they’re not cruel in the right hands.

Are prong collars safe? Usually, but if a prong collar is used incorrectly, it can cause serious injury to the dog. For example, if the collar is too tight, it can restrict the dog’s airway and cause difficulty breathing. If the prong points are sharp, they can puncture the skin and cause bruising or, even worse, internal damage. Some manufacturers cut corners when it comes to prong collars, so be prepared to pay a little extra for a proper prong collar that’s been blunted.

It’s important to use prong collars with caution and to consult with a professional trainer before using one on your dog. However, with proper use, prong collars can be effective training tools that help you achieve your desired results without causing any harm to your dog’s neck.

Thank you for reading! I assume that you want to have a good relationship with your dog and that you’ve come away thinking, “prong collars if necessary, but not necessarily prong collars.” Good like with your dog training efforts, and remember, if you’re out of your league, you can always consult a pro.


Related Content:

3 Steps to Choosing the Right Dog Collar
The Best No-Pull Dog Leads and Collars
Shock Collars May Soon Be a Thing of the Past – Positive Reinforcement Will Lead the Way in Training